Proposal Review

Reviewer Form

  • Objective or purpose provides a well developed focus/issue/problem related to teaching and/or curriculum.
  • Proposal provides a sound methodology (if research study) and/or philosophical, theoretical, or practical argument connected to the focus/issue/problem indicated.
  • Argument/analysis is well supported by findings (if research study) and/or claims made.
  • Justifies presentation's contributions to the world of teaching and/or curriculum.
  • Proposal explains how the session promotes a timely/relevant discussion, raises pertinent issues and is of relevance to AATC members.
  • Add the total points for the five items above. The maximum score (3 for each item) is 18.
  • Please include comments that might be helpful to the conference program chair
  • Please include constructive comments to be forwarded to the author.